An Interview with Dr. Betty
Kamen
Hormone Replacement Therapy: Yes or No? How to Make an Informed Decision
Q: As many as 90 percent of the American female population suffers from
PMS and/or menopausal symptoms. Is this unique to the U.S. or is it universal?
A: These syndromes are not universal. There are cultures in the world
where the words for PMS or hot flash do not even exist. Not all postmenopausal women
develop osteoporosis!
Q: Physicians now add progesterone to the estrogen they prescribe for
menopausal women. Is this an advantage?
A: There is a great deal of confusion surrounding the proper use of
the term progesterone. Progesterone or natural progesterone refers to one specific hormone
- the one manufactured by your adrenal glands or ovaries. What you need to know is that
most of the so-called "progesterone" added to replacement therapy is usually
synthetic, resembling the hormone made in your body, but differing in significant ways.
Synthetic progestins (a more accurate term for unnatural progesterone) may have serious
side effects. Natural progesterone has none.
Q: Then why don't the drug companies use the natural product?
A: A natural hormone (found in humans or anywhere in nature) cannot be
patented by a pharmaceutical company. A slight variation of the hormone, however, can be
patented! Does this explain the popularity of synthetic hormones promoted by the drug
companies?
Q: Just how do the natural and the synthetic progestins differ?
A: The distinction between progestins and natural progesterone is
important. The only thing synthetic progestins and natural progesterone have in common is
their ability to sustain human secretary endometrium. Among the side effects of synthetic
progestin are weight gain, bloating, and cancer. To add to the problem, synthetic
progestogins diminish your supply of natural progesterone! (1) Estrogen, by the way, helps
to slow down bone loss. Natural progesterone builds bone back!
Q: Do we understand how natural progesterone helps to build bone?
A: We're just beginning to understand the metabolism involved. Natural
progesterone affects osteoblasts, our bone-building cells. So natural progesterone is
proving to be a valuable agent for the prevention of osteoporsis, and for the management
of postmenopausal osteoporosis.
Q: Is it true that hormone residues fed to animals are found in our
foods?
A: A mounting body of evidence suggests that other sources of estrogen
are contributing to the back-ground level of carcinogens in our food environment.
Q: What are the sources of natural progesterone?
A: A major source is the Mexican yam. A substance from this vegetable
is extracted and then converted to the same chemical structure as natural progesterone. It
is then usually mixed in a cream base and applied topically. This transdermal route for
replacement therapy does not have the adverse effects of synthetic progestins.
Q: How long has natural progesterone been available this way? Has it
been used long enough to verify results?
A: Some physicians have been prescribing transdermal progesterone for
as long as twelve years. They report fantastic results, quoted in my new book, Hormone
Replacement Therapy: Yes or No / How to Make an Informed Decision - not only for relieving
PMS symptoms, but also for menopausal problems.
Q: What prompted you to research natural progesterone?
A: My research actually started with estrogen. The information in the
medical journals is alarming. For example, there is a 46 percent increase in ischemic
stroke risk among nurses using estrogen replacement therapy, despite the fact that the
group studied was comprised of women with less diabetes, less cigarette smoking, and less
adiposity than those not using estrogen. (2) And very significant, I learned that lack of
estrogen does not cause osteoporosis. Here's one example of how we know this: Tamoxifen is
an anti-estrogen drug given to breast-cancer prone women. This drug blocks the uptake of
estrogen hormones. If lack of estrogen is the cause of osteoporosis, one would expect that
tamoxifen would increase bone resorption and cause loss of bone density. Tamoxifen does no
such thing!
Q: What about calcium for our bones? Doesn't that work?
A: More than calcium is needed for healthy bones. No published study
sheds useful light on the question of how much calcium is necessary for bone health. There
is little direct evidence of the effectiveness of calcium intake as a preventive strategy
for hip fractures. Iron, zinc and magnesium intake are positively correlated with forearm
bone mass content in premenopausal women. This suggests that bone mass is influenced by
dietary factors other than or in addition to calcium. Women should know that chlorinated
water, especially if consumed on a high fat diet, reduces calcium absorption. Almost all
tap water is chlorinated.
Q: How serious is the threat of hip fracture for American women?
A: Adult women face at least a 15 percent lifetime risk of a hip
fracture. The annual costs of hip fractures alone are estimated at $7.3 billion in the
United States.
Q: What advice would you give to women who are facing menopause?
A: The most important suggestion is to learn the pros and cons of
hormone replacement therapy. Learn, too, about the wonderful track record of natural
progesterone. Then discuss what you know with your physician, and together you can make a
truly informed decision. Just remember that you do NOT have to suffer - with either PMS or
menopausal symptoms. There are safe ways to adjust your metabolism. They are neither
complicated or expensive, nor are they health-impairing. In fact, you may find that some
of your other problems will disappear as you attempt to regulate your hormone metabolism
with natural substances such as progesterone.
|